Reviews of Property: Waterfront View of New York City from a Vintage Home

Description House, 900 sq. ft.,
2 Bedrooms, Sleeps 6, 1 Bathroom
Facilities village, waterfront, garden, air-conditioning, internet access, satellite or cable
Rates per property
Set rates in US Dollars
$135 - $230/night 
$950 - $1,450/week 
$3,000 - $4,000/month 
GBP Conversion - Estimated
£81 - £138/night 
£569 - £868/week 
£1,796 - £2,395/month 

26 Reviews of Property 168637 in Staten Island, USA

Rating
5 out of 5

Back in the New York Groove!!

Swan Valley Australia
Review Submitted: October 25, 2009 Date of Stay: September 2009
My husband and I took our 3 children (ages 17, 14 & 11) to New York from Perth, Australia in early October. This was a return trip for us and a new experience for them.
Finding accommodation for five people at a reasonable rate is not an easy assignment! Robin's accommodation is exactly as described and portrayed in her photos.
The easy ferry access to Manhattan, the ability to travel on the subway to all points, the ability to find some space and to cook our own meals - all these wonderful points are eclipsed by the owner herself.
Robin is a wonderful landlord - she is there when needed to provide good local information but does not intrude. She was especially helpful to us in obtaining tickets to a Giants game for my husband and son - which has given them both some great memories.
I have no hesitation in recommending a stay with Robin at this, or any of her other properties.

Our love & best wishes to Robin

Margaret (John, Bradley, Kelsey & Brittany) Perth - 2009
Recommended for:  Age 55+, Pet-friendly, Girls Getaway, Tourists without a Car, Sightseeing, Families with Teenagers, Romantic Getaway
Did you find this review helpful? Yes No
Rating
4 out of 5

Stay here the next time you run the NYC marathon

JodiandNate Minneapolis MN USA
Review Submitted: November 8, 2009 Date of Stay: October 2009
My husband and I and another couple rented this lovely home when we ran the 2009 NYC marathon. Getting the shuttle to the start line was a piece of cake, just a five block walk to the ferry terminal, where runners, biffy's and many marathon shuttles were waiting. Convenient to many good restaurants (walk a bit more down Bay Street to the blue restaurant) including the tapas Beso and Italian Enoteca. Only downside was the loud street traffic when you're trying to sleep. Not a big deal though, pros far outweigh the cons.
Recommended for:  Age 55+, Girls Getaway, Tourists without a Car, Sightseeing, Families with Teenagers, Families with Young Children, Romantic Getaway
Owner's Response: The street noise on Staten Island is far quieter than in Manhattan, Brooklyn or Queens anywhere at any time. This is still the city if New York, the biggest town in the USA.
But Jodi and Nate were wonderful and if they visit next year for the Big Run I will supply them with ear plugs.
Did you find this review helpful? Yes No
Rating
4 out of 5

a lovley stay

Bert & Ilse and Dirk Netherlands
Review Submitted: August 20, 2009 Date of Stay: August 2009
We stayed in the appartment with 3 people for 6 days (august 2009)
It is a very good place to stay if you want to visit New York.
You don't need a car but if you have one parking is free on your doorstep.
The ferry takes you in 25 min to manhattan. just perfect.

The house clean and lovely decorated although its not my style.
Every room has an AC so after a hot day in the city you can enjoy the coolnes en quietnes of the house and staten Island
In the morning and evening is the view magnificent

The police station is 1/2 mile away so you feel safe even at night when you return form the city

The tappas bar 2 blocks away (accros from the ferry) is the best restaurant in the area.
The Owner who lives upstairs gave us good advise about going out in new york and staten Island....

Small stores for daily groceries and a laundry are in 8 min walking distance.

Perfect place for a good price and warm-hearted owner.
Recommended for:  Tourists without a Car, Sightseeing, Romantic Getaway
Did you find this review helpful? Yes No
Rating
5 out of 5

Great to see NYC without all the hustle and bustle

Cincinnati Kid Cincinnati, OH USA
Review Submitted: August 19, 2009 Date of Stay: August 2009
We loved the accomodations and location. Far enough away from the city to not feel overwhelmed, but just a short free ferry ride to lower Manhattan.

We had 4 adults, 2 teens and 1 baby and were very comfortable in the house. Robin, the owner, was very accomodating and provided just about everything you'd need to be comfortable. We thoroghly enjoyed our 4 night stay!
Recommended for:  Tourists without a Car, Sightseeing, Families with Teenagers, Families with Young Children
Did you find this review helpful? Yes No
Rating
5 out of 5

Fantastic stay

nomiddlename England, UK
Review Submitted: June 14, 2009 Date of Stay: April 2009
We had a fantastic stay in this lovely apartment.

Our party consisted of 4 adults - mum, dad and 2 grown up children. This apartment worked well for us with there being a comfy sofa bed in the lounge (along with 2 bedrooms), internet access for everyone and the kitchen well equipped for us all.

It really was easy going into Manhattan with the free ferry and access from there onto the subway.

We also visited various outlets/shopping at Short Hills (thanks for the tip, Robin) and Woodbury Common (about an hour away). These were great and it was much cheaper shopping there rather than on Manhattan. To do this we hired a car and parked outside the apartment for free.

A few restaurants/shops nearby but we tended to eat while we were out and about rather than nearby.

While we were there it was pretty cold but the heating provided plenty of warmth and was quite instant, with it being steam driven.

Robin is available to help if you need it or leave you alone if you would prefer. We would definately return and we recommend to friends and family.
Recommended for:  Age 55+, Adventure Seekers, Girls Getaway, Sightseeing, Families with Teenagers, Romantic Getaway
Did you find this review helpful? Yes No Helpful votes: 1/1
Rating
4 out of 5

Great few days in NY in great Location

Mojmir Sydney, Australia
Review Submitted: May 19, 2009 Date of Stay: March 2009
We are a couple from Australia and we spent a great 5 days exploring New York from this great location just a half hour free ferry ride (across the Bay) from Manhattan. Accommodation is located in a house with lounge overlooking the Hudson bay to NY skyline and a short 10 minute walk to the ferry. We used the ferry and then the subway each morning and returned late at night to our cozy, clean, well furnished, self contained, two bedroom flat in a safe area. Our host Robin was a helpful source of information and provided us with some good tips on things to do, see and the most efficient way to move around this great city and maximize our time there. There are some shops located on way from the ferry to stock up on groceries or to grab a quick snack (open from early in the morning to late at night). There is street front parking available. If no car we would recommend booking a taxi service which services the Staten Island area as most yellow cabs and normal transfers are for hotels and accommodation in Manhattan.
Recommended for:  Age 55+, Tourists without a Car, Sightseeing, Families with Young Children
Did you find this review helpful? Yes No Helpful votes: 1/1
Rating
5 out of 5

marathon stay

marathon family gettysburg, pa
Review Submitted: January 9, 2009 Date of Stay: November 2008
My husband ran the new york marathon...this lovely home was the home base for he, myself and our teenage daughter. Robin, the owner, was extremely helpful...the place has many wonderful extras you would never get in a hotel...she even delivered items we left behind(thanks again, Robin)

Short walk to ferry...free 20 minute ride...amazing night photos of NYC skyline and the Statue of Liberty.

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay...and plan to stay again in the future...and have recommended it to many friends.
Recommended for:  Age 55+, Tourists without a Car, Families with Teenagers, Romantic Getaway
Did you find this review helpful? Yes No
Rating
5 out of 5

Great

Floridafolk Sarasota, Florida
Review Submitted: November 10, 2008 Date of Stay: October 2008
The description of the property was accurate. Truly, we thought it was better than the description. We had a wonderful stay! Frank is originally from Brooklyn and occasionally likes to escape sunny Florida and go back to touch home-base. We wanted to book what he calls "a hub and spoke" trip and of course, he wanted a bargain rate...this couldn't have been better. We flew into NY, rented a car and drove to our home (the Hub) for 2 weeks. Harbor House was an immaculate, warm, safe and inviting house. Everything we needed to make ourselves at home was provided. Parking was free - and right in front of the house. The owner, Robin, was friendly and helpful, and clearly cared about everything being "just so" for her guests. We unpacked once and then began venturing out to new places each day. Most days, we left the car and went into Manhatten on the Ferry (a short walk to the Ferry and a delightful, free 20 minute trip into the city) for dining, Broadway plays, concerts, museums, walking different areas of the city. Other days we took the car and went Frank's to old haunts in Brooklyn, visiting family and friends in the area and shopping in NJ, one day we took a trip up to the catskills and enjoyed the beauty of fall color, another day we went to Atlantic City. There were even terrific restaurants and golf, etc. on Staten Island (who knew!). We will definitely do this trip again and highly reccommend it. If you know the area around the city, a car is nice to have for jaunts into the countryside...if you don't know the area, stick with reliable, bargain public transportation in the city. Great trip.
Recommended for:  Age 55+, Tourists without a Car, Sightseeing, Families with Teenagers, Families with Young Children, Romantic Getaway
Did you find this review helpful? Yes No Helpful votes: 2/2
Rating
5 out of 5

Great Stay!

NY Tourist Toronto Canada
Review Submitted: October 14, 2008 Date of Stay: October 2008
Just got back from a fantastic stay here. Great location, great property, all as advertised. The owner Robin was available and helpful when required. We are a family of five that drove down from Toronto Canada and things couldn't have worked out better. We are all ready planning on returning.
Did you find this review helpful? Yes No
Rating
5 out of 5

The Dutch are back on Staten Eiland!

De Joostens Nijmegen, Netherlands
Review Submitted: August 19, 2008 Date of Stay: July 2008
After reading the reviews on the site we, (a Dutch family with two teenage kids) decided to book the Hudson Harbour view house (or Manhattan skyline view!) for this year's USA vacation. No regret!. Ideal for European first timers! All the reviews are correct. Everything is fine, even the small details like coffee, tea, toiletpaper already in te house so there's no need to hurry to the shop. We left almost every day after a good homemade breakfast at app. 10.00 AM lazy and cozy to the Ferry terminal. In less than an hour we were in downtown NYC! And, the returning Ferry trip is an excellent way to calm down from the Manhattan hectic. To avoid killing shopping trips with wife and daughter to NYC we took the Staten island bus (valid with the NYC Metrocard) to the Staten Island Mall, after visiting our colonial heritage in historic Richmond Town (boring according to my daughter, not the shopping part!)
Still a pity that we sold all this to the British a couple of centuries ago......
During the rest of our visit to the USA we kept a pleasant email contact with the owner. She is really great: she leaves you alone if you wish to be, but always available as an NYC tourist board volunteer. Thank you Robin! You can see the result of all your efforts on this site: the house is booked full for a large period!
A last remark for my compatriots: renting this house for a week is much cheaper than two manhattan hotelrooms for the same period
Recommended for:  Tourists without a Car, Families with Teenagers
Did you find this review helpful? Yes No Helpful votes: 5/5